Non-rp killing - broader rules clarification and discussion requested

[Crashlander04]

[quote='FinnBalto' pid='44759' dateline='1335723364']


1.2: Respect Your Fellow Players - lack of respect for a fellow player by presuming everyone between home and site of attack is a valid kill target

3.1: Don’t Seek Unfair Advantages - full on attacking someone who's turned to face you, doesn't have a drawn blade, and is making no motion either towards or away

4: Maintain The Theme of The Server - this is, I believe, an RP server first and foremost. PvP is supposedly conincidental to that.

7: Roleplay - none occurred prior to the kill
7.2: Metagaming - Pwol is very aware that I am an RPer and knows I would engage in dialogue prior to any attack, even when justified.
7.3: Powergaming - Abusing the rules of roleplay to obtain an unjustified kill.

Listed.

lol

3.1 - Dont see how I had an unfair advantage, seems like we both had armor, in fact his happened to be enchanted

4 - He was in the territory of an enemy I was raiding, and posed a threat

5 - Like I said I was raiding, no time to stop and say "Excuse me sir, you are in enemy territory, whilst im raiding, time to die"

7.2 - Metagaming seriously, give me a break.....

7.3 - Like stated I am on a raid, plenty of RP.

Sure do, he was sitting right on their town's nether portal. That very well counts as their terf.

If that is so the case, then the situation is simply based on misfortune and wrongful assumption of the characters involved respectively. Then there is no real problem other than your character being an asshat - which, I might add, is not ban-able.