Non-rp killing - broader rules clarification and discussion requested

[Smythie]

So you're saying that giratina should be banned because he is too good at PvP, even though he wants to rp now... Faith in humanity, gone.

Just because a convicted murderer says he'll be a good boy and become a gardener or something doesn't mean that he should be released from prison. Nice try though.

Convicted murderer? wtf.

It's just an example.

And a bad one at that. Giratina is not anywhere close to a convicted murderer, maybe a self-taught professional but he wants to rp and thats what strikes me as awfull. He wants rp but you wont let him.

No my example was that giratina is banned= murderer in jail. He "wants to rp" = Murderer says he will be good. It doesn't mean we let the convicted murderer out of jail because of what he will do. That's what the example was. Way to comprehend