Hmm.
You should meat Cerce, he is an expert at Rant's on Role-play. No offense Cerce.
I did play Warcraft 3, and i will agree with you, RP on there sucks.
Maps such as School life, got ruined from being a good map, to just total out, i'm better than you.
I'm not an avid roleplayer myself, i'm not for it, or against it, but i am quite good at it.
And of course, the classic excuse of "Playing minecraft is roleplaying".
It is, but not to the extent at what you are trying to get at, or what Cerce is trying to get at, and I wish that most people would get that.
I do think that since i have played Warcraft 3 before, and seen at what horrible roleplayers those people area, i can see where you are coming from, and why you can rant on, and i would rant with you, except for one fact, the amount of Role-play on Kiwike amazed me from the 1.0-pre 2.0-2.0 transfer. If you saw that, you would of saw how far we have come from a flimsy group of friends, building towns, to the Knights of Dusk, and people like Cerce. It amazes me.
Your rant in my mind, deserves a 10/10, even though i preferred Vamps

.