No/Bad RP Reasons for killing

[TheCreator]

If you wanted to punch him in his face, you should have done "/me looks at Rathrok with an angry facial expression as he tightens his right fist and then drops a punch towards Rathrok's face. Do I succed doing so? If not give me a reason why I didn't succed."

"he simply would have fought back"
So he didn't even fight back? Great just great, now it makes your point even more valid.

And could you prove that you didn't just make it up as an excuse? The facts are pointing the other way and you are clearly using it as a excuse anyways.