No/Bad RP Reasons for killing

Leech · 04-09-2012, 17:52,

I find it humorous that Crash is ENTIRELY ignoring this in the powergaming sense. It is an RP reason, and the thread title may be misleading, but it is Powergaming

yottabyte Wrote:*Thief: Hand over your money or die!
*Player: No, I will not hand over my money!
*Thief: /Thief stabs the player repeatedly till he dies and takes his money anyway/

(04-09-2012, 16:00)Rathrok Wrote: Crashlander: Hello sir.
Me: Human...
Crashlander: Im No Human!
Me: Doesn't matter to me...
Crashlander: Look i'll prove it to you!

Sounds like similar justification if you ask me

Crashlander04 · 04-09-2012, 18:14,

Powergaming? Should I wait before I finish killing him to see if he has any last words (which would result in him killing me)? Should I instead let him kill me? Should I brush his teeth and tuck him into bed as well? Maybe get him a nice cup of tea?

Just because I proceeded to kill him doesn't make it powergaming. I said I'd prove it (ie; I'm not a weak human) and proceeded to kill him. This shouldn't be classified as powergaming just because I didn't ask him for permission to kill him.

However, if I had typed /me kills Rathrok and takes his stuff - and he had no choice but to comply, it would be powergaming.

Rathrok · 04-09-2012, 18:21,

Thats right, just completely bypass rule 7.3 cause it doesn't count for you Jackie / Head is full of f**k

bonden · 04-09-2012, 18:24,

haha crash did u prove you wherent a human by killing him thats not even a resone to kill him xD i mean if u want to prove it just tell him your name and the place u came from xD i mean killing him proves nothing that doesnt prove that you are a human /are not a human

Cell · (This post was last modified: 04-09-2012, 18:30 by Cell.)

I believe that it could of been solved much more easier, although some might not do this, or never thought of it.
Insulting his race is more than a good enough reason to kill, but if Crash realized, as Rathrok pointed out, he had no way of knowing he was a dwarf. Rather if this was real life, his short height, beard, etc, would of shown it.

Quote:Crashlander: Hello sir.
Rath: Human...
Crashlander: Im No Human!
Rath: Doesn't matter to me...
Crashlander: Look i'll prove it to you!

Quote:Crashlander: Hello sir.
Rath: Human...
Crashlander: ((I'm a dwarf))
Rath: ((My bad, stupid Minecraft characters))
Crashlander: ((No worries))

Problem could of been solved easily, rather then Rath complaining about the Minecraft characteristics, and Crash defending his race. In all RP reasoning, it is a perfect reason for him to kill you. It would be the same if you walked up to Tristo in-game and told him that Humans and his kind are no different, it is an insult to his race, providing an RP reason for him to well, murder you.

Oh, and why are you posting this if it happened two days ago, and besides, this is the third or fourth thread we have on this topic.

Smythie · 04-09-2012, 18:31,

I believe there is a reason to keep posting about these non/bad rp kills Cell because so far nothing has been done to stop it.

Crashlander04 · 04-09-2012, 18:34,

There's a difference between RP kills that you disagree with, and Non-RP kills entirely.

Cell · 04-09-2012, 18:34,

(04-09-2012, 18:31)Smythie Wrote: I believe there is a reason to keep posting about these non/bad rp kills Cell because so far nothing has been done to stop it.

Like I said in the other thread just a minute ago. I'm against it in a way, but it can't be stopped as everyone has their own RP, allowing for any odd ball reasons to kill someone. Wether it is justified or not.

Rathrok · 04-09-2012, 18:35,

I've only posted about this because i thought that nothing could be done about it previously, when i was looking through the forum today, i saw that other people had similar problems. Also smythie is right, the only reason that so many people are posting about it is because it is a big problem that needs to be solved, and fast.

Android · 04-09-2012, 18:36,

I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.