No/Bad RP Reasons for killing

Crashlander04 · 04-09-2012, 18:41,

(04-09-2012, 18:36)Android Wrote: I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.

Well, he apparently looks down on humans, and if he is so much more superior he would have been quite surprised for a dwarf to overpower him. Not to mention I've already given utter reasoning. It can be decided that my character handled the situation aggressively (however wrong it was is up to one's own opinion), but nothing more I believe.

Can we lock this thread if it is simply an argument back and forth about opinions? - especially if no verdict is being made.

Smythie · 04-09-2012, 18:42,

(04-09-2012, 18:41)Crashlander04 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:36)Android Wrote: I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.

Well, he apparently looks down on humans, and if he is so much more superior he would have been quite surprised for a dwarf to overpower him. Not to mention I've already given utter reasoning. It can be decided that my character handled the situation aggressively (however wrong it was is up to one's own opinion), but nothing more I believe.

Can we lock this thread if it is simply an argument back and forth about opinions? - especially if no verdict is being made.

No verdict has been made so should we not keep it open?

Ian25 · 04-09-2012, 19:21,

(04-09-2012, 18:42)Smythie Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:41)Crashlander04 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:36)Android Wrote: I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.

Well, he apparently looks down on humans, and if he is so much more superior he would have been quite surprised for a dwarf to overpower him. Not to mention I've already given utter reasoning. It can be decided that my character handled the situation aggressively (however wrong it was is up to one's own opinion), but nothing more I believe.

Can we lock this thread if it is simply an argument back and forth about opinions? - especially if no verdict is being made.
No verdict has been made so should we not keep it open?

think about it, if someone comes up to you and says "east side fag!" and then you corrected him by saying "im no eastside junkie!" and then he proceeded to say "w/e". You'd be offended too, get in a fight and probably seriously injure or kill him.

Crashlander04 · 04-09-2012, 19:29,

damn east side..

Rathrok · 04-09-2012, 19:34,

(04-09-2012, 19:21)Ian25 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:42)Smythie Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:41)Crashlander04 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:36)Android Wrote: I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.

Well, he apparently looks down on humans, and if he is so much more superior he would have been quite surprised for a dwarf to overpower him. Not to mention I've already given utter reasoning. It can be decided that my character handled the situation aggressively (however wrong it was is up to one's own opinion), but nothing more I believe.

Can we lock this thread if it is simply an argument back and forth about opinions? - especially if no verdict is being made.
No verdict has been made so should we not keep it open?

think about it, if someone comes up to you and says "east side fag!" and then you corrected him by saying "im no eastside junkie!" and then he proceeded to say "w/e". You'd be offended too, get in a fight and probably seriously injure or kill him.

But i didn't exactly say anything aggresive or anything to annoy him apart from getting his race wrong (which isn't at all easily identifiable). If you've ever played a Fantasy rpg game, its quite common for characters to identify eachother by race. such as dragon age, where humans & elves greet eachother as just that. as for the 'doesn't matter to me...' i was simply not interested in having a conversation, not asking for a fight as this assface seems to have thought i'd said.

Ian25 · 04-09-2012, 19:34,

ikr? :lol:

Crashlander04 · 04-09-2012, 19:36,

1. blatant flame.
2. I gave my reasoning for character interpreting this as offensive.
3. Ian, who's side are you on? XD

Ian25 · (This post was last modified: 04-09-2012, 19:38 by Ian25.)

(04-09-2012, 19:34)Rathrok Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 19:21)Ian25 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:42)Smythie Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:41)Crashlander04 Wrote:
(04-09-2012, 18:36)Android Wrote: I do believe that's the only reason he is posting it now, Cell, because of the other threads that had been popping up.

This brings to my attention the fact that you mustn't have cared that much about it at the time, seeing as how nothing was done about it (or maybe I'm wrong and you did try to contact a moderator). Otherwise, I do believe Cell's solution is what should have taken place. From what I can gather, that's the only real reason he called you a human, Crash, and he wouldn't have otherwise offended you (although he does go on to say it doesn't matter to him).

Anyways, I don't believe killing him was a valid way to display you not being human for one, you could have easily displayed it via voice/chat, and two, even a human could have killed him, the swords in Minecraft are universal.

Well, he apparently looks down on humans, and if he is so much more superior he would have been quite surprised for a dwarf to overpower him. Not to mention I've already given utter reasoning. It can be decided that my character handled the situation aggressively (however wrong it was is up to one's own opinion), but nothing more I believe.

Can we lock this thread if it is simply an argument back and forth about opinions? - especially if no verdict is being made.
No verdict has been made so should we not keep it open?

think about it, if someone comes up to you and says "east side fag!" and then you corrected him by saying "im no eastside junkie!" and then he proceeded to say "w/e". You'd be offended too, get in a fight and probably seriously injure or kill him.

But i didn't exactly say anything aggresive or anything to annoy him apart from getting his race wrong (which isn't at all easily identifiable). If you've ever played a Fantasy rpg game, its quite common for characters to identify eachother by race. such as dragon age, where humans & elves greet eachother as just that. as for the 'doesn't matter to me...' i was simply not interested in having a conversation, not asking for a fight as this assface seems to have thought i'd said.

assface, hahahah. but you have to realize that his character is constantly putting up with this human shit, and instead of saying sorry, you ignored him.

(04-09-2012, 19:36)Crashlander04 Wrote: 1. blatant flame.
2. I gave my reasoning for character interpreting this as offensive.
3. Ian, who's side are you on? XD

that first post was aimed at your eastside comment.

Rathrok · 04-09-2012, 19:44,

Sounds like plain ol' powergaming to me tbh.

asdfasdflkjty911 · 04-09-2012, 20:02,

I feel like half the community who dies in game will cry over non RP kills.

Just because something is vague doesn't mean it isn't RP. You offended him, and he attacked back. Leave it at that.