Non-rp killing - broader rules clarification and discussion requested

[Sebiale]

I don't have diamonds because I have no use for them.

[Crashlander04]

I don't have diamonds because I have no use for them.

don't glorified librarians need diamond swords and armor? ;P

[Sebiale]

I don't have diamonds because I have no use for them.

don't glorified librarians need diamond swords and armor? ;P

I barely bother with iron armor.

[Smythie]

I just realised that no action was taken over this. Pwol broke at least 6 rules and he wasn't even warned?

[Pwol]

I just realised that no action was taken over this. Pwol broke at least 6 rules and he wasn't even warned?

List em

[bowser956]

1.2: Respect Your Fellow Players - lack of respect for a fellow player by presuming everyone between home and site of attack is a valid kill target

3.1: Don’t Seek Unfair Advantages - full on attacking someone who's turned to face you, doesn't have a drawn blade, and is making no motion either towards or away

4: Maintain The Theme of The Server - this is, I believe, an RP server first and foremost. PvP is supposedly conincidental to that.

7: Roleplay - none occurred prior to the kill
7.2: Metagaming - Pwol is very aware that I am an RPer and knows I would engage in dialogue prior to any attack, even when justified.
7.3: Powergaming - Abusing the rules of roleplay to obtain an unjustified kill.

Listed.

[Smythie]

I just realised that no action was taken over this. Pwol broke at least 6 rules and he wasn't even warned?

List em

Way to read the initial post

[Pwol]

1.2: Respect Your Fellow Players - lack of respect for a fellow player by presuming everyone between home and site of attack is a valid kill target

3.1: Don’t Seek Unfair Advantages - full on attacking someone who's turned to face you, doesn't have a drawn blade, and is making no motion either towards or away

4: Maintain The Theme of The Server - this is, I believe, an RP server first and foremost. PvP is supposedly conincidental to that.

7: Roleplay - none occurred prior to the kill
7.2: Metagaming - Pwol is very aware that I am an RPer and knows I would engage in dialogue prior to any attack, even when justified.
7.3: Powergaming - Abusing the rules of roleplay to obtain an unjustified kill.

Listed.

lol

3.1 - Dont see how I had an unfair advantage, seems like we both had armor, in fact his happened to be enchanted

4 - He was in the territory of an enemy I was raiding, and posed a threat

5 - Like I said I was raiding, no time to stop and say "Excuse me sir, you are in enemy territory, whilst im raiding, time to die"

7.2 - Metagaming seriously, give me a break.....

7.3 - Like stated I am on a raid, plenty of RP.

[Smythie]

1.2: Respect Your Fellow Players - lack of respect for a fellow player by presuming everyone between home and site of attack is a valid kill target

3.1: Don’t Seek Unfair Advantages - full on attacking someone who's turned to face you, doesn't have a drawn blade, and is making no motion either towards or away

4: Maintain The Theme of The Server - this is, I believe, an RP server first and foremost. PvP is supposedly conincidental to that.

7: Roleplay - none occurred prior to the kill
7.2: Metagaming - Pwol is very aware that I am an RPer and knows I would engage in dialogue prior to any attack, even when justified.
7.3: Powergaming - Abusing the rules of roleplay to obtain an unjustified kill.

Listed.

lol

3.1 - Dont see how I had an unfair advantage, seems like we both had armor, in fact his happened to be enchanted

4 - He was in the territory of an enemy I was raiding, and posed a threat

5 - Like I said I was raiding, no time to stop and say "Excuse me sir, you are in enemy territory, whilst im raiding, time to die"

7.2 - Metagaming seriously, give me a break.....

7.3 - Like stated I am on a raid, plenty of RP.

Wait you know an enemy who owns the nether?

[Pwol]

[quote='FinnBalto' pid='44759' dateline='1335723364']


1.2: Respect Your Fellow Players - lack of respect for a fellow player by presuming everyone between home and site of attack is a valid kill target

3.1: Don’t Seek Unfair Advantages - full on attacking someone who's turned to face you, doesn't have a drawn blade, and is making no motion either towards or away

4: Maintain The Theme of The Server - this is, I believe, an RP server first and foremost. PvP is supposedly conincidental to that.

7: Roleplay - none occurred prior to the kill
7.2: Metagaming - Pwol is very aware that I am an RPer and knows I would engage in dialogue prior to any attack, even when justified.
7.3: Powergaming - Abusing the rules of roleplay to obtain an unjustified kill.

Listed.

lol

3.1 - Dont see how I had an unfair advantage, seems like we both had armor, in fact his happened to be enchanted

4 - He was in the territory of an enemy I was raiding, and posed a threat

5 - Like I said I was raiding, no time to stop and say "Excuse me sir, you are in enemy territory, whilst im raiding, time to die"

7.2 - Metagaming seriously, give me a break.....

7.3 - Like stated I am on a raid, plenty of RP.

Sure do, he was sitting right on their town's nether portal. That very well counts as their terf.