The ban list.

theonedoctor · 09-30-2012, 23:58,

(09-30-2012, 23:56)iDieForEXP Wrote: So since I have a shiny new title, my view on the moderation of these bans is that they were banned for Revamped. If the 2.0 esqe server retains the name of Revamped, then they should remain banned. However, the rp server should get its own ban list.

Gonna throw your weight around now?

Cell · 10-01-2012, 00:00,

(09-30-2012, 23:56)iDieForEXP Wrote: So since I have a shiny new title, my view on the moderation of these bans is that they were banned for Revamped. If the 2.0 esqe server retains the name of Revamped, then they should remain banned. However, the rp server should get its own ban list.

I feel as though if you are banned on the RP server, you should be banned on the 2.0 style server, and vise versa.

iDieForEXP · (This post was last modified: 10-01-2012, 00:07 by iDieForEXP.)

(09-30-2012, 23:58)theonedoctor Wrote: Gonna throw your weight around now?

I will try to avoid that to the best of my ability.

(10-01-2012, 00:00)Cell Wrote: I feel as though if you are banned on the RP server, you should be banned on the 2.0 style server, and vise versa.

I can see your point there, but I think some of the rules on the hardcore side may be a bit more strict, and so if someone were banned for excessive meta gaming or power gaming, then I think they should still be able to play on the other server. Now if its for a more serious offense... they may be banned for both, I'm not sure how Yotta wants to handle that.

theonedoctor · 10-01-2012, 01:17,

(10-01-2012, 00:04)iDieForEXP Wrote:
(09-30-2012, 23:58)theonedoctor Wrote: Gonna throw your weight around now?

I will try to avoid that to the best of my ability.

(10-01-2012, 00:00)Cell Wrote: I feel as though if you are banned on the RP server, you should be banned on the 2.0 style server, and vise versa.

I can see your point there, but I think some of the rules on the hardcore side may be a bit more strict, and so if someone were banned for excessive meta gaming or power gaming, then I think they should still be able to play on the other server. Now if its for a more serious offense... they may be banned for both, I'm not sure how Yotta wants to handle that.

Dont worry i know you wont i think you will do a good job EWBTE

iDieForEXP · 10-01-2012, 03:10,

Well thank you, although we should get back on topic.

sethd13 · 10-01-2012, 03:16,

You dont have the title yet, I can still call you biased and not get banned :3

ConcernedCitizen · (This post was last modified: 10-01-2012, 04:30 by ConcernedCitizen.)

The real question about the bans is if the reset should be complete or partial. That is, should we allow everyone to start with a clean slate or should we make an exception for the big names (jyan, terion, pav, Ian, Giratina, Nlewis, Pwol, Sparky, Ryan, etc). keeping them banned

iDieForEXP · 10-01-2012, 04:32,

For the rp server, I will push for a clean slate. As for Revamped, not my business Tongue

bvcxzmn · (This post was last modified: 10-01-2012, 05:02 by bvcxzmn.)

(10-01-2012, 04:28)ConcernedCitizen Wrote: The real question about the bans is if the reset should be complete or partial. That is, should we allow everyone to start with a clean slate or should we make an exception for the big names (jyan, terion, pav, Ian, Giratina, Nlewis, Pwol, Sparky, Ryan, etc). keeping them banned

hgodwhy:

I know JYanowitz IRL (went to middle school and go to high school with him). Do not let him back on Kiwike!!! He has not learned his lesson or evolved his thinking in the slightest, he will continue to do the things that he was banned for!

Crashlander04 · (This post was last modified: 10-01-2012, 05:08 by Crashlander04.)

(10-01-2012, 04:28)ConcernedCitizen Wrote: The real question about the bans is if the reset should be complete or partial. That is, should we allow everyone to start with a clean slate or should we make an exception for the big names (jyan, terion, pav, Ian, Giratina, Nlewis, Pwol, Sparky, Ryan, etc). keeping them banned

I think it can be said without any argument Pavja and Jyan each did a considerable amount more harm than Ian, Lewis, Pwol, and Giratina ever did combined.

Hypothetically, (with Pavja and largely memorable griefs as exceptions) the more prominently known names are due to the large amount of controversy that surrounded cases - making the crime much less definitive (probably a bad word for it) or simply subjective. Whereas the less known permanbanned are blatant hackers, griefers, and x-rayers who were indisputably banned. If anything, the controversial cases are the ones who deserve (at least more than the other cases) compassion the most.